Thursday, April 29, 2010

Do bears Shi’ite in the woods?

Religion, eh? Woooh. Tough one. In response to images of Mohammed in a bear suit being snipped from South Park, artist Molly Norris created this:


but then had a change of heart, which she attempted to explain with this:


Now, the most reductive explanation was that she was scared of decapitation, which was the implied threat that had led the South Park episode to get cut. But it’s all a bit more complex than that. Norris’s whimsically satirical suggestion for a ‘Draw Mohammed Day’ was intended to be a statement of support to the beleaguered South Park creators, and a statement of support for free speech; but inevitably it also attracted a fair share of people who just hate Muslims, which made her feel uncomfortable. So in the end she did this:


I wouldn’t presume to tell Molly Norris what she should and shouldn’t do with her pictures; an artists doesn’t necessarily have any social or moral obligations. But I might point out that it can sometimes be more effective to avoid statements altogether, and just to ask questions. Questions such as: “Why are you scared of cartoons?” for example.

Thanks to Dick Headley for flagging this one up. On vaguely related lines, and to show it isn’t just Muslims who suffer from humour fatigue, here’s Cristina Odone claiming that the BBC has it in for Catholics after she was harangued by a stand-up comedian; and yet the self-same organisation tuts at a different stand-up for comparing Palestine to a cake “being punched to pieces by a very angry Jew”. Now, I’d argue that (leaving aside for the moment the uncomfortable status of the word ‘Jew’, as opposed to ‘Jewish person’) Boyle’s line is worthy of TS Eliot, and a far more successful piece of art than the South Park bear or Norris’s doodles or the shrill hectoring of either Hughes or Odone. And one or two Muslims might agree with me. But does that make it OK?

As I said, tricky one.

3 comments:

blackwatertown said...

All jolly good.
But I never expected I'd find myself sympathising with Christina Odone against Sean Hughes. Of course, it could be the way she tells it.
Meanwhile, the person I'm really cross with is Gordon Brown. How dare he suck so much of the long term fun out of the election (the slight uncertainty, tension, etc) for the sake of an admittedly hilarious, but all too brief, comedic flash. I need something very bad from the other two to balance things out again. Cameron to shoot someone? Clegg caught in flagrante backstage with a fragant member of the final TV debate? Suggestions?

Tim Footman said...

No, Clegg caught in flagrante with Cameron, Brokeback Mountain style; Brown in the outraged Randy Quaid role.

Word is that on polling day, Mrs Duffy will be on page 3 of The Sun.

blackwatertown said...

Speaking of religion - you've probably seen this already. But just in case http://monicks.net/2010/04/05/an-open-letter-to-religious-people/#comment-2013